General Notes

Joshua Bailey Richmond identified the wife of Edward Richmond (#104, son of Capt. Edward & Sarah Richmond) as Rebecca Thurston, daughter of Jonathan and Sarah Thurston, b. 28 Nov 1689.  4 daughters from this marriage are enumerated — Sarah (b. 20 Dec 1711), Mary (b. 1714), Priscilla (b. 27 Feb 1718 and married Samuel Hart of Little Compton on 19 Mar 1733), and Eunice (b. 23 Sept 1722).   All daughters were said to be born in Little Compton according to the birth records of Little Compton.

However, Joshua Bailey Richmond ALSO has this same Rebecca Thurston marrying Edward Richmond (#11, b. 8 Feb 1665 in Taunton, son of John Richmond & Abigail Rogers).  Marriage date is almost identical (6 March 1711 instead of 6 May 1711), and similar 4 daughters are enumerated — Sarah (b. 20 Dec 1711 and married first Josiah Washburn and 2nd Samuel Crane), Mary (b. 1714 and married Edmond Burt), Priscilla (b. 27 Feb 1718 and married John Hackett), and Eunice (b. 23 Sept 1722, but presumed to have died young).  The daughters are referred to in the will of Edward Richmond (son of John and Abigail, died 1741 in Taunton).

Sources other than JBR have Rebecca Thurston as being born in Little Compton.  They show another marriage to Peter Worden after the death of Edward Richmond (JBR#104, b. 1689 Little Compton).  Daughter Sarah Richmond is married to Caleb Carr, but with a slightly different birthdate in 1711.  Daughter Eunice, rather than dying young (as presumed by her lack of mention in ER's will), appears to have married a James Cranston in Rhode Island.

My conlusion is that there were two different Rebeccas married to two different Edward Richmonds.  They had similarly named daughters.
Rebecca Thurston from Little Compton married the Edward Richmond of Little Compton.  I am changing the Rebecca Thurston that Edward Richmond of Taunton married  to "Rebecca unknown".  May 2008.  kmh.  (It is also possible that both women were named Rebecca Thurston.)

~~~~~~~~~~~